How To Appraise A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis in Clinical Practice- Dr Sanil Rege

Posted on: February 22, 2016
Last Updated: October 20, 2020

A systematic review is a comprehensive review of primary studies addressing a clearly formulated question using systematic and explicit methods to identify, select and critically appraise relevant research. Meta-analysis is the mathematical synthesis of the primary studies in a systematic review to give a pooled estimate of effect size.

Advantages of systematic reviews and meta-analyses
• Explicit methods are used in identifying and excluding studies based on strict inclusions and exclusions criteria. This limits bias.
• It increases the power of the study by combining different studies, thus increasing the probability of finding a truly significant effect and reducing type II error, i.e. false negative. (This is mainly through a meta-analysis, i.e. quantitative systematic review)
• Large amounts of information can be assimilated quickly by healthcare providers, researchers, and policymakers.
• Prevents or reduces the delay between research discoveries and the implementation of effective diagnostic and therapeutic strategies.
• The results of different studies can be formally compared to establish generalisability of findings and consistency of results.
• Reasons for heterogeneity (inconsistencies) can be identified, and a new hypothesis can be generated for different subgroups.
• It allows for a more objective appraisal of evidence and a more reliable and accurate result due to the methods used.
• Promising research questions to be addressed in future studies may be generated, and the sample size needed in future studies may be calculated accurately.


Learn more

  1. The Neurobiology of Trauma and PTSD Phenotypes – Dr Sanil Rege
  2. Clozapine Mechanism of Action and Augmentation Strategy – Dr Sanil Rege
  3. Pathogenesis and Diagnostic Indicators for Antiphospholipid Syndrome (APS) in Psychiatry-Dr Sanil Rege
  4. Antiphospholipid Syndrome and the Brain (Neuropsychiatric Manifestations of APS) – Dr Sanil Rege
  5. Techniques to Prepare For the EMQ and Critical Analysis (MCQ) Problems – RANZCP Written Exam-Dr Sanil Rege
  6. Passing the Modified Essay (MEQ) and Critical Essay (CEQ) Exam- RANZCP- Dr Sanil Rege
  7. Essential Mental Models for A Psychiatrist – The Art of Complex Problem Solving- Dr Sanil Rege
  8. Observed Clinical Activity (OCA) and MEQ – Passing the RANZCP Exam- Dr Sanil Rege
  9. Sanil Rege on Education and Entrepreneurship – Podcast
  10. A Summary of 3 Important Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorders for Psychiatrists – Dr Sanil Rege
  11. Neuroinflammation Simplified – The Link Between the Immune System and The Brain- Dr Sanil Rege
  12. Q & A Session on Neuroinflammation in Psychiatry – Dr. Sanil Rege
  13. What is Regression Analysis in Critical Appraisal? – Dr Sanil Rege
  14. Principles of Entrepreneurship and Innovation in Medicine – Dr Sanil Rege
  15. The Power of Serendipity and Multidisciplinary Learning in Medicine – Solving a Complex Clinical Case- Dr Sanil Rege
  16. Psychiatric Formulation and Management- Tips and Techniques- Dr Sanil Rege
  17. Psychiatry Exams – What’s the Right Mindset?- Dr Sanil Rege
  18. Psychiatry Trainee to Consultant Psychiatrist – Skills Breakdown- Dr Sanil Rege
  19. From Psychiatry Trainee to Consultant Psychiatrist – Stages of Training for the RANZCP Exams- Dr Sanil Rege
  20. From Psychiatry Trainee to Consultant Psychiatrist- Dr Sanil Rege